×
Zoom
 
HOME/FORUMS/CHARACTER DESIGN CONTEST

Roro Son and Iguana (CLOSED)

eye917
Thread Activity
RodaNaSun, Nov 24, 2024
Other decisions are not up to me but It's up to me to submit my work. Hope you enjoyed my work tho!
polygionaryMon, Nov 18, 2024
Oh mate! I completely understand where you're coming from, and I share your views on this situation. I, too, never wanted things to get so complicated
3113pixelsMon, Nov 18, 2024
I feel like you are forcing my hand here, and I want it on the record that I wish this wasn't happening :') I feel horribly awkward and partially like
RodaNaMon, Nov 18, 2024
There was no rule stated that participants have to start all of the process including concept art when the contest starts. Just the application period
3113pixelsSun, Nov 17, 2024
Thank you! It's difficult to speak up about because I really don't want to bring anyone down, in any way, especially if it was down to a misunderstand
polygionarySun, Nov 17, 2024
I completely agree with you. I have many WIP projects and I could upload any of them here as if I were making a new one, but it's not fair, it's not c
3113pixelsSun, Nov 17, 2024
I wasn't going to weigh in, but this is just a really unfair misrepresentation.The issue isn't that you were "using sketches" of a character from befo
RodaNaWed, Nov 13, 2024
Well, I shared what I understood about the contest entry.It might be that I misunderstood. But in my opinion, using old sketches or recent sketches to
RodaNaSat, Oct 26, 2024
Karma: 310


Roro Son is an experimental character who wants to escape from 'being defined' by social class, appearance and any kind of judgeable elements. But classification, definition, organization are enforced in human being's brains naturally. In this situation, not to be defined as a certain 'type' of person, Roro starts to appear with unidentifiable costumes that cannot be interpreted instantly and acts in unconventional ways. Even if her behavior might look weird on the outside, the eventual goal of her eccentricity is to explore how to create myself as an organism, instead of relying on belonging to certain groups that are already defined in the society. Iguana is Roro's little friend.

To express this concept, costumes were designed to not remind people of any strong images. It doesn't seem to have a clear function, and all fashion props are asymmetric. The shapes of patterns on her clothes are irregular and uncertain.

The character was designed by Roda Na from scratch. Hand-drawn 2D illustration that was an initial concept art was transferred to the props and costumes with a model in the real world to formulate realistic references for 3D production. And finally, based on 2D illustration and model shots, final character creation was done in 3D.

Maya, ZBrush, Arnold renderer, Ornatrix, Marvelous Designer, Nuke, Substance 3D Painter, Substance 3D Sampler, and Photoshop were used.




Full Body Shots of Roro Son and Iguana

Forum Image
Forum ImageForum ImageForum Image

Wireframes
Forum Image

Front / Sides / Back Views of the Full Body
Forum ImageForum Image

RodaNaSat, Oct 26, 2024
Karma: 310
Roro Son Face Closed-up Shots
Forum ImageForum ImageForum Image



RodaNaSat, Oct 26, 2024
Karma: 310
Iguana-focused images
Forum Image
Forum Image
Forum ImageForum Image


Front / Sides / Back Views of the Iguana
Forum ImageForum ImageForum Image
RodaNaSat, Oct 26, 2024
Karma: 310
Close-Up Shots of the Costume
Forum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum Image
RodaNaSat, Oct 26, 2024
Karma: 310
Concept Development Process
- 2D Character Illustration
- Real Model shots with Costumes Transferred from the 2D Illustration
- Craft-Making Process
Forum ImageForum ImageForum Image
Forum Image
RodaNaSat, Oct 26, 2024
Karma: 310
Concept Development Process2
- Cinematic Reference Image Making
Forum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum Image
loivaMon, Oct 28, 2024
Karma: 110
This is so good!
But if I’m not mistaken this was not made for the challenge. This was made 70+ weeks ago(almost a year).

And if I’m not mistaken the creatures or characters needed to be created just for this.

It’s pretty sick not the less
loivaMon, Oct 28, 2024
Karma: 110
Forum Imagelike here it says 49 w :c
RodaNa
Karma: 310
Mon, Oct 28, 2024
Hello, thanks for checking out my account. My concept art was ready last year. And only a rough dummy was in progress.

But all the 3D works and texturing was done very recently like 1 week ago. I finished making reel 3 days ago. I saw the advertisement of this contest from Siggraph 2024 in July. And it motivated me to make complete work and deliverables for this contest. I have been aiming to submit my work to this contest and it has been my pivot since I saw this contest, otherwise I wouldn't have been able to finish this work.

I am a character artist and have many concepts and ideas ready always. I don't think using my original ideas I have come up with can be a problem. This contest is open to all kinds of concept and I thought this contest was perfect and wonderful to showcase my complete work. I really appreciate that I was able to discover this opportunity.

Thank you
Tommygherkins
Karma: 102
Mon, Oct 28, 2024
beautiful design. but i think that rule is there to ensure everyone has the same amount of time to conceptualize and make an original character specifically for this competition. i did check out your Instagram and i notice that you posted this character sketch on the 11th of March 2023 a year and a half ago and said it was for your thesis. your cosplay is really impressive but was finished by the 8th of May 2023 and on the 18th of November 2023 it looks like you made a pretty good start on the 3d sculpting for this character. you say you did "all the 3d works and texturing" 1 week ago but on the 18th of september which is over a month ago you posted this exact character in an instagram post even down to the exact facial expression just in a different colourway. again it is a great design but it is breaking the first rule of this competition that was in bold on the original post:

This is a 3D modeling contest requiring a completely original character that you have created for this contest.

which is not very fair on the other people who have only had 2 months to design and create their characters
RodaNa
Karma: 310
Mon, Oct 28, 2024
Hello, thank you for your attention.
My work was still in progress a month ago. It was fully done last week on Thursday Oct 28th, including texturing, lighting, rendering, compositing, and making a reel. It hasn't submitted to any other contests and to market. My complete work was submitted to this contest for the first time as soon as it was done.

Up to our judges smile

Thanks
RodaNa
Karma: 310
Mon, Oct 28, 2024
* done on Oct 24th, not Oct 28th. Sorry for the confusion.
loiva
Karma: 110
Tue, Oct 29, 2024
but is the same thing. What if someone took a year to create something super detail and then post it here saying. Ah yes I did the textures yesterday smile

I think might not be fair tbh, but still. Up for the Judges smile
RodaNa
Karma: 310
Tue, Oct 29, 2024
Yeah Thanks!^^
hnso23Tue, Oct 29, 2024
Karma: 102
your work is so awesome i can see many art work in this site and i attrectived most. insane iguana skin is crazy!!!wow
RodaNa
Karma: 310
Tue, Oct 29, 2024
Thank you so much!
Samantha 08Tue, Oct 29, 2024
Karma: 290
Absolutely gorgeous work!
RodaNa
Karma: 310
Tue, Oct 29, 2024
Thank you very much‍♀
SF_ModelingWed, Oct 30, 2024
Karma: 312
Incredible work and very good presentation, congratulations
RodaNa
Karma: 310
Thu, Oct 31, 2024
Thank you so much! I am also glad that this project is done. I am excited for the next project!
RodaNaThu, Oct 31, 2024
Karma: 310
Work In Process

ZBrush
(from start to end)
Forum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum Image
Forum Image
Forum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum Image
RodaNaThu, Oct 31, 2024
Karma: 310
Work In Process

Marvelous Designer
(from start to end)

1st layer
Forum Image

Sleeves add
Forum Image

2nd layer(pants) and socks
Forum Image

1st layer, 2nd layer, and socks
Forum Image

Vest
Forum Image

Forum ImageForum Image

Ribbon
Forum Image
Forum Image
Forum Image



RodaNaThu, Oct 31, 2024
Karma: 310
Work In Process

Substance 3D Painter

-Iguana
(from start to end)

Forum Image
Forum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum Image
RodaNaThu, Oct 31, 2024
Karma: 310
Work In Process

Substance 3D Painter
-Human Skin
: To save the render time, only visible parts were painted. 

Face base color
Forum ImageForum Image

Face subsurface color
Forum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum Image
Forum Image

Embroidery pattern design
Forum Image


Forum Image
Forum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum ImageForum Image
RodaNaThu, Oct 31, 2024
Karma: 310
Work In Process

Maya
-Scene
Forum Image

-Hair Grooming with Ornatrix
Forum Image
Forum Image
RodaNaThu, Oct 31, 2024
Karma: 310
Work In Process

Test Renders
(Render trials and errors)

Forum Image


HDRI test

Forum Image
RodaNaThu, Oct 31, 2024
Karma: 310
Work In Process

Renderfarm and Nuke
Forum Image
Forum Image

Forum Image

Forum ImageForum Image

RodaNaThu, Oct 31, 2024
Karma: 310
Thumbnail

Forum Image
Senimation
Karma: 683
Thu, Oct 31, 2024
Wow, the amount of details are amazing!
Especially the iguana looks so realistic! : )
RodaNa
Karma: 310
Mon, Nov 04, 2024
Ohh thank you so much. I am glad to hear that!
jamie6Mon, Nov 04, 2024
Admin: 14,433
Forum Image
Thumbnail for contest gallery
RodaNa
Karma: 310
Fri, Nov 08, 2024
Thank you!
jamie6
Admin: 14,433
Fri, Nov 08, 2024
Best of luck!
bonjTue, Nov 12, 2024
Karma: 15,160
Not an original character specifically for this competition.

As mentioned above (your Instagram and i notice that you posted this character sketch on the 11th of March 2023 a year and a half ago).
RodaNa
Karma: 310
Wed, Nov 13, 2024
Hi! I think I need to clarify what I thought. It is clear that the concept art was ready last year. I didn’t intend to hide that. You can see my concept art posting even on my website. The truth is that Roro Son is my original character I made from the beginning.

I thought it would be fine to submit the final work for this contest even if the progress started earlier, as long as the final work was not submitted to any other contests or markets for other purpose. To me, the contest description didn’t clearly mention that all works need to be started when the contest starts. Also, many contests require people to submit works that haven’t been submitted to other contests, so I interpreted this case as the same way.

Also, my work is new. This was newly showcased to this contest. During the last 3 months, I did my best to infuse a life into my character that was living in my brain. I knew RenderHub already. But when I saw their contests before, I wasn’t ready. I was looking forward to having another chance to submit my work to the contest thrown by RenderHub. I was so glad when I saw this opportunity again. I hope there’s respect.

Thank you.
bonj
Karma: 15,160
Wed, Nov 13, 2024
quote
"To me, the contest description didn’t clearly mention that all works need to be started when the contest starts."


It clearly states

"This is a 3D modeling contest requiring a completely original character that you have created for this contest."

https://www.renderhub.com/3d-contests/character-design-contest

I think many would interpret that as stated, an original character that you have created for this contest including the concept. Yes you may have an old sketch or idea that could suit the event but not a full design. I have a tone of old figures I could have pretended to be new.

However this is a good opportunity to introduce and showcase your work well done for that. You have some great skills, I wish you good fortune in your creative endeavours.

It is disingenuous to say you made an original character for this event. However you word salad your response. The simple question is did you make this character including final concept for this event? No the final design is a year and half old.

Maybe I am wrong and concepts from years ago are fine as long as the build and production was done recently.

No disrespect is intended, even though respect is a thing that is earned and not automatic. I can be respectful and speak my mind here on RH as much as I do when involved with any production. One of the many great things about RH.

I am a little "picky" I'm sure a few other people feel the same about interpretations of the rules. Being honest a lot of other people have invested a lot of work into entering this event with a NEW and original character. I don't care who wins as long as we get an honest result that was made for the event. I'm sure most people would be satisfied with that.
RodaNa
Karma: 310
Wed, Nov 13, 2024
Well, I shared what I understood about the contest entry.
It might be that I misunderstood. But in my opinion, using old sketches or recent sketches to create characters for the contest was artist’s discretion. If you had many sketches you have made before, I think you could use them for 3D production this time. Anyway I am not a decision-maker on it.

I wish you the best of luck and thank you for sharing your thoughts.
3113pixels
Karma: 392
Sun, Nov 17, 2024
I wasn't going to weigh in, but this is just a really unfair misrepresentation.

The issue isn't that you were "using sketches" of a character from before the contest, the issue is that your character was actually modelled before the 18th of November 2023, over a year ago, as per your own Instagram, specifically for your thesis, not for this competition.

You also used the exact character with different textures for a flier for "Fake and Gay and AV Club SF" on your Instagram on the 18th of September, a month before posting anything to this competition. So as per the rules, which were clarified on the FAQ page to say:

"2. Entries must be new original work specifically made for this contest.
This means you can not use a previously created character as your entry."

Your character was modelled over a year ago, not since August 1st. It has been used both for your thesis, and for a flyer, not created for this competition. And I think it is unfair for you to imply you only "used sketches" you had done before August the 1st when the entire character was modelled and being used for other things by then.

As cool as the character is, of course, it is not fair to enter in a competition like this, at all.
polygionary
Karma: 337
Sun, Nov 17, 2024
I completely agree with you. I have many WIP projects and I could upload any of them here as if I were making a new one, but it's not fair, it's not challenging And when we all have to do everything from scratch, which is pretty time consuming, someone can use such a cheat. And I am offended by it.
I also agree that the character is great, but it's unfair and insulting to the participants who did everything honestly.
3113pixels
Karma: 392
Sun, Nov 17, 2024
Thank you! It's difficult to speak up about because I really don't want to bring anyone down, in any way, especially if it was down to a misunderstanding of the rules, but at this point it's really just not fair to everyone who put their all in, and managed to follow the rules, and it was my last straw when I read they're being dishonest about it only being "sketches".

This wasn't sketches, nor a WIP (which would have been bad enough), this character was done for a literal thesis project over a year ago, and used for a flyer months ago, just so obviously and undeniably not made for this competition, and clearly finished ages ago.

It's also a shame because it would've been great to see what this artist would've created in a fair competition.
RodaNaMon, Nov 18, 2024
Karma: 310
There was no rule stated that participants have to start all of the process including concept art when the contest starts. Just the application period was for 3 months. I didnt think that this was a 3 months time limit competition until somebody left a reply on my post. My Roro character was properly showcased to the RenderHub contest first. 

And again, my work is new. I shared the renderfarm records to show when this project was prepped to showcase. Modeling was not done last year. I didnt have even costume. This character was what I have always wanted to make. I decided to go through the rest of the progress of this character for this contest, and to showcase this character for this competition since I saw this competition’s advertisement at the Siggraph 2024 in Denver in July. For the last 3 months, I made so much progress. I spent most of time in front of the computer, not sleeping. 

Modeling progress was completely done in September. I did texturing one by one in August when single prop was ready. I finished texturing at the beginning of October. I had to fix models for some parts, and added more props while texturing. I did shader-making in Maya, while texturing at the same time. I started the rendering process in October. I had to fix some shaders, texture maps, and lights at this time. I started making a reel during the end of October. Many of these processes overlapped in time. 

I thought I had to post my work as a complete presentation when it is done. After uploading my stuff, I realized that some people posted progress as it comes. I didnt know that was possible cause I havent seen that kind of posting method. It doesn't mean that my process was done long time ago.

I did my best to meet the qualifications under my understanding.
3113pixelsMon, Nov 18, 2024
Karma: 392
I feel like you are forcing my hand here, and I want it on the record that I wish this wasn't happening :') I feel horribly awkward and partially like this is not my place, but as someone who put a lot of work into my characters, and know a lot of other people did too, without just using whole characters we had already made, I think it's important in the interest of fairness and integrity to show why so many people are making the same remarks.

Here are the proof shots from your Instagram page @na_roda.

Showing:
Your post from 8 May 2023 of your character cosplay, finished.
Your post from 18 November 2023 of your character modelling, substantially done.
Your post from 18 September 2024 of the character, with the same facial expression, in different textures, used for a flyer that is nothing to do with Renderhub nor this competition, posted prior to you starting this thread on Renderhub, proving the character was finished, rendered, and used for something else entirely before entering here.


Forum Image
Forum Image
Forum Image
Forum Image

And a repost of your thumbnail which I hope will become the main photo again as it is last:

Forum Image
polygionary
Karma: 337
Mon, Nov 18, 2024
Oh mate! I completely understand where you're coming from, and I share your views on this situation. I, too, never wanted things to get so complicated, but unfortunately, it seems there's no way to avoid it now. Honestly, it’s difficult for me to even express these thoughts.

What I find particularly concerning is that Roda used this character for the 'Fake and Gay' flyer, even though she was aware that it doesn't align with the contest rules. At the same time, she seems to be positioning herself as unaware of the issue. Our concern isn't with reusing the original concept, but rather with the attempt to present the situation in a way that doesn’t align with the facts. From Roda's Instagram, it's clear that this character was started (in 3D) quite some time ago, so it's hard to see how there could be any misunderstanding.

I feel sorry for Roda, but I cannot stay aside
RodaNa
Karma: 310
Sun, Nov 24, 2024
Other decisions are not up to me but It's up to me to submit my work. Hope you enjoyed my work tho!
Close WindowRenderHub Login

Show Password

Reset password
Create Account