×
Zoom
 
close x
Horrific Render Contest 5 – $3,800 In Prizes – Ends October 31st»  click for contest rules and prizes  «
HOME/FORUMS/TECHNICAL TALK

Photoshop alternatives

eye485
Thread Activity
MasterstrokeSat, Aug 01
Thank you everybody, for your tips.I've tried, tried them all. My conclusion is as much as I hate to say it, that only photoshop is photoshop.I am ru
Luxe MuseThu, Jul 30
hi, hi, hi. My work here is done! :P
deathdThu, Jul 30
Wow, the GIMP is pretty good now actually. Not perfect, but very usable.
deathdWed, Jul 29
Thanks. Been probably more than a decade since I tried the GIMP, should probably revisit that and see how it has improved.
Luxe MuseWed, Jul 29
Gimp girl over here. I also use Paint.net a lot. But as far as Gimp, if you wanna make it feel photoshopy, there's a community plugin for that: https:
deathdWed, Jul 29
For real photomanip stuff, haven't found anything as good. I use photoshop as little as possible, partly because I have to reboot and log into windows
MasterstrokeWed, Jun 17
Karma: 6,138
I have dissed effing Adobe long ago, and had Affinity, PaintShopPro, and Gimp, but they are all a fail, when it comes to layers.
Till now Photoshop seems to be the only tool, that does it right, but I just don't want to go back.
What I need to do:
-Select and copy a single part of an image and paste it in place.
-Transform and edit the element in the new layer
What sounds like the most easy thing fails in any other app, I've tested. 
Either the background layer is getting invisible as soon as you click the new layer element (PaintShopPro)
or the background layer always moves with the selected top layer (Affinity),
or you're lacking options like free transformation, rotation (Gimp).
It might be all available with some extra keyboard shortcut, but if I was good with keyboard shortcuts, I would have been a rich pianist by now.
And Photoshop proves, that it can be done quick and easy, but EFF Adobe!
So if anybody knows a tool that handle layers exactly the photoshop way, please let me know.
Thank you. 

KuraiKyaWed, Jun 17
Karma: 23,598
Try Paint.Net
Luxe Muse
Karma: 9,337
Wed, Jul 29
I love Paint.Net, but unfortunately it's layer approach is very, very basic frown
ArodiaWed, Jun 17
Karma: 8,701
Krita is pretty good, with reasonably intuitive interface. 
Masterstroke
Karma: 6,138
Wed, Jun 17
I had some success with Krita.
At least layer system works nice, but I ran into the problem, how to feather selection and brush tools.
Didn't know it yet.
Hyp-StWed, Jun 17
Karma: 16,611
Another voice for Krita. It's become quite powerful program over the years.
Pushee-RiWed, Jun 17
Karma: 52,920
What about the 'legendary' Photoshop CS2?
It's old and no longer runs on Windows 11... but this version (if you read the info carefully) has a very compelling advantage wink
ProPose001
Karma: 212
Sat, Jun 20
Been using CS2 for years. No muss, no fuss
Pushee-Ri
Karma: 52,920
Sat, Jun 20
You're right smile

And the right key is the KEY emote
Masterstroke
Karma: 6,138
Sat, Jun 20
And where to still get it from?
Pushee-Ri
Karma: 52,920
Sat, Jun 20
Check your PM smile
Wolf007Wed, Jun 17
Karma: 319
Gimp has Unified Transform Tool (their version of free transform) that you can select manually after pasting (no need of shorcut) mantaining the bounding box of the tool to your selection.

I do imagine does not work exactly like photoshop tho.

Now, trying Krita is a good option too. From your example, it does have options about what to copy and many options on how to paste (as new layer is not from Edit menu, is from Layer one).


guy91600Wed, Jun 17
Karma: 21,536
Sometimes I use PhotoFiltre; it's free software for Windows.
I have the French version; I don't know if there's a version with English menus. It's also a good opportunity for English speakers to understand the difficulties we encounter with an interface in a language we only speak partially fluently smile
https://www.photofiltre-studio.com/download-en.htm
bu_esWed, Jun 17
Karma: 12,370
photopea is online editor clon of phohoshop https://www.photopea.com/. Although I still work with my Photoshop CS6
Masterstroke
Karma: 6,138
Wed, Jun 17
It might be powerful, but I absolutely don't like browser apps.
But thank you smile
thirdeyezennicai
Karma: 30,077
Sat, Jun 20
Photopea I actually use quite often when I'm not in the mood for Photoshop's bullshit; not exactly the best but it does wonders.
TenserknotSat, Jun 20
Karma: 11,059
Every online app steals your data. 
Masterstroke
Karma: 6,138
Sat, Jun 20
Or cencoring it..
like
"sorry, we detected inappropiated content, that does not match our guidelines in your workflow.
the app will not procede and has to be shut down.
Please read and follow our guidelines and try again.
Thank you for your understanding "
Tenserknot
Karma: 11,059
Sun, Jun 21
steals 'AND' censors.

first you have to upload , they save it to their servers, then they analyze, and then it determines you can't use the service on top of that.

Slipknot3DMon, Jun 22
Karma: 10,705
Still use photoshop cs2 as well! been clicking on "do not register" for many years lol
Pushee-Ri
Karma: 52,920
Mon, Jun 22
Same goes for me ..... and yeah.... you don't have to click on everything, after all emote
Shahadat 4DWed, Jul 29
Karma: 104
Try "Photopea", it's free, browser-based and mimics Photosop's layer handling almost exactly, same select, copy, paste in place, then transform and rotate freely on the new layer. 

Also worth trying "Krita", its layer and transform tools feel closer to Photoshop than Gimp or Affinity ever did. 
deathdWed, Jul 29
Karma: 1,666
For real photomanip stuff, haven't found anything as good. I use photoshop as little as possible, partly because I have to reboot and log into windows to use, and partly because a lot of what I used to do in photoshop, I figured out how do with free stuff like krita now, and stuff like painting is better in krita now that I am used to it. There is some things I haven't figured out how to do as well, like touching up photos fast. The clone tool in krita is just not as simple as heal brush in photoshop for quick skin retouches. It doesn't seem to be able to blend as well no matter what I try.
Luxe MuseWed, Jul 29
Karma: 9,337
Gimp girl over here. I also use Paint.net a lot. But as far as Gimp, if you wanna make it feel photoshopy, there's a community plugin for that: https://github.com/Diolinux/Photogimp if you want to give gimp a second chance.
deathd
Karma: 1,666
Wed, Jul 29
Thanks. Been probably more than a decade since I tried the GIMP, should probably revisit that and see how it has improved.
deathd
Karma: 1,666
Thu, Jul 30
Wow, the GIMP is pretty good now actually. Not perfect, but very usable.
Luxe Muse
Karma: 9,337
Thu, Jul 30
hi, hi, hi. My work here is done! emote
MasterstrokeSat, Aug 01
Karma: 6,138
Thank you everybody, for your tips.
I've tried, tried them all. 
My conclusion is as much as I hate to say it, that only photoshop is photoshop.
I am running very quickly into walls with every tool like Paint Shop Pro Gimp, Krita or Affinity.
Didn't use in Browser tools, for they are a strikt nogo for me.
In fact, I wonder if Photoshop would be still Photoshop with all its AI cr@p.
I will keep searching...

Close WindowRenderHub Login

Show Password

Reset password
Create Account